18 Comments
User's avatar
Dbn123's avatar

Amit, a big part of Israel’s PR problem in the US, and in fact a big problem for all Jews in the US is the fast-growing Muslim demographic. Michigan is practically Iran and many inner US cities are beginning to resemble the French African arrondissements in Paris. That is, these areas are all virulently anti-Semitic and anti-Israel.

Leaders of these groups — people like AOC, Mamdani, Omar — hate Jews, hate the American way and are more loyal to Muslim countries than to Washington.

Also, young left-wing, rich white kids see Israel and Jews as the white oppresser class and Palestinians as the black people of the 1950’s and 1960’s. This is all false of course as Israel has a higher percentage of non-white citizens, but that’s not the perception of the rich, white college student.

Israel and American Jews need to find a way to fight back against these groups before, like in 1930s Germany, it is too late.

Les Vitailles's avatar

"young left-wing, rich white kids see Israel and Jews as the white oppressor class"

More precisely, these mediocrities see Jews as a weak target they can attack without consequences. They were wonderfully described by Spencer Pratt:

"An entire generation of spoiled brats who’ve never built anything, stand on the crumbling empire they don’t deserve, built by great and courageous men who are now judged through the moral lens of the softest dorks living in the easiest times. Oy vey."

During the Floyd riots of 2020 it was all against "white supremacy", until they realized that whites are 70% of the American population and much too big a target to tackle. They've turned on the Jews instead.

JasonT's avatar

Yeah, they have tired of beating up on Christians.

Mycroft's avatar

Cant forget that in 1900 there were 15 Moslems in the world for every Jew now more than 100 Moslems per Jew

Mycroft's avatar

Sort of agree.demography changes.Michael Oren pointed out when NYC elected à Moslem mayor why be surprised number of Moslems and Jews roughly equal in NYC. Islam according to a recent Pew analysis will be the world’s largest religion in 2035 surpassing Christianity.

Also cant forget that impact of Holocaust has receded the youngest person who was alive at the end is 81. Israel loved it, remember Yad Vashem which combined scenes of the persecution and murder, but ends open the door and seeing Arei Yehudah.

Alison Cipriani's avatar

Amit, get over it. Perhaps Israelis have been shielded from reality but this is normal. What we experienced in the US after WWII was the exception not the rule. It's their problem and there's not much we can do about it. We have a long way to go economically before we approach anything resembling Israel in the 1950s. We’ll survive. Shabbat Shalom

NANCE SCHMANCE's avatar

I love languages, and right now am learning Hebrew, and my heart leapt to know what you wrote! The first letter I learned after the alef and bet was SHIN! God bless you! Shabbat Shalom!

MyaMaryca's avatar

Praying that all in potential leadership positions would be open to Ruach Hakodesh and that He would unite Israelis for the glory of G-d and the good of the nation.

NANCE SCHMANCE's avatar

Amen - Maranatha! <><

Arthur Reynolds's avatar

Your optimism is astounding given that any future act of self-defense will be an act of "genocide" and the USA has decided to rid itself of protecting Israel. Then again, when the Ultra-Orthodox dont believe Israel is worth fighting for and many Jews seem ambivalent towards the Zionist Project. alas perhaps its time to envision an end to the Jewish State and create an exit strategy before extermination. Who is to blame for this very sad state of affairs: the politicians who have ruled Israel since 1967. (I would remind you all dear friends that the USA and West European polities have demographically transformed beyond recognition........). Shalom.

זכרון דברים's avatar

I find it strange that you told us that you are related to Rabbi MH Hirsch.

Yet, Professor Sarna's closer familial connection to you goes ignored.

Peter Donner's avatar

Israel doesn't need a new story, it needs to stop it's apartheid in the West Bank, stop it's Gaza genocide, and stop it's destruction in Lebanon. Israel will be hated by most Americans until it stops it's war crimes. If Netanyahu remains prime minister the US will abandon Israel

NANCE SCHMANCE's avatar

You need to watch the 45-minute film the terrorists filmed on Oct. 7; you need to see the pictures they posted, listen to the audios they sent their praising parents and families after beheading, roasting alive, burning alive, I can't type the rest, of babies, children, teens, parents, grandparents, some Holocaust survivors. Israel did not start this war and there is NO genocide in Gaza. You've allowed your emotions to rule you over truth and facts. And the whole Land God gave His People Israel is massive - from the Egyptian peninsula down into NW Saudi Arabia, Iraq, all the way up the Syria and Lebanon. You did get one part correct - Many, NOT most, Americans will hate Israel, which is why we're incurring God's Wrath right now - Pres Trump claiming HE saved Israel & warning PM Bibi to not finish the job - because America is NOT to be found in the entire Holy Bible - but Iran, S.A., Jordan, Libya, Sudan, Turkey, Lebanon, AND ISRAEL are. And God is going to protect His People and His Land Israel - His Words, not mine. The US will not abandon Israel if PM Bibi remains; it will when there is a demonrat in Our White House. Bible prophecy, 1/3 of the Holy Bible, is being fulfilled at lightning speed. I pray you ask God to reveal Himself to you. Clock's ticking. Shabbat Shalom from a born-again Christian Israel supporter in the U.S.

Ric Victor's avatar

That phrase is plainly manufactured by the commienazi/dsa left as a psy-op.There's so little contact between israeli pop culture and us alleged youth culture or pop or even news culture that it could not occur organically.

Saul's avatar

Suspect "the cool kids" are confusing Tel Aviv with Doha. Only the former is organic.